
1. Regarding Human Exceptionalism
Why are humans so arrogant and callous when it comes to animal issues?
Obviously, self-interest plays a part – humans believe that they benefit
from eating, wearing, experimenting on, and otherwise exploiting nonhumans.
But, there appears to be more to the story, because most people do not
justify abuse of animals on the grounds of “might makes right” but rather
because nonhumans are “inferior” by virtue of lacking human intelligence,
the human capacity to suffer, or a “soul.”
In previous essays, I have explored how humans’ desire to feel immortal
might contribute to callousness toward nonhumans. Humans often want to
perceive themselves as fundamentally different and far more important than
nonhumans, because nonhumans appear to live, struggle, and die without
evident cosmic importance. Do we have the same fate as nonhumans, as the
writer of Ecclesiastes asserts (Ecclesiastes 3:19-21)? If so, does that mean
that once we die that is the end of our story and our sense of being
vanishes forever? Such a prospect is discomforting for many people and
encourages them to regard humans as infinitely more valuable and important
than nonhumans, however the flimsy the arguments for such a stance might be.
Next week, I will consider how the human tendency toward tribalism might
contribute to humanity’s general disregard for nonhumans.
Stephen R. Kaufman, M.D.
2. The October “Peaceable Table” Is Now Online
Contents include:
To read in this issue, visit http://www.vegetarianfriends.net/issue129.html.
Toward the Peaceable Kingdom,
Gracia Fay Ellwood, Editor
3. This Week’s Sermon from Rev. Frank and Mary Hoffman
Weeping Over Sins versus Obedience